Showing posts with label welfare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label welfare. Show all posts

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Don't blame welfare

So I met up with a new acquitance recently, and somehow we got to discussing the economic downturn.

She mentioned something I didn't quite understand, something about being in the grocery store and seeing very well dressed people paying for their groceries with food stamps.  It seemed like she was implying that people were scamming off the food stamp program, that they were really rich enough to afford nice clothes, but somehow they were stealing from the hard working tax payer to get food stamps.  And this was somehow related to the economic downturn, as she then started to talk about women who have too many children and just live on welfare for fun.  She mentioned something about all this welfare spending being the downfall of the American economy and ruining the government budget.

REALLY???

Just to say it to everyone who might ever read this, welfare spending is less than 1% of the American budget.  If you add in food stamps, it's about 2.5%.

Compare to, say, the military budget, which is somewhere between 20-35% depending on who you ask.

How could helping those in need lift themselves out of poverty, care for themselves and their children possibly be creating the economic downturn?  And yes, we have a serious national debt problem, I will agree there, but cutting welfare isn't even going to be a drop in the bucket.

In many countries, on the other hand, that have even better welfare benefits than we do, many of the recipients more quickly get back on their feet and back to work than they do here in America.  Of course it's difficult to sort out the causes of that, but it might be that with enough help someone can actually mainstream themselves more easily than with a tiny pittance that just keeps them alive.

I should add a note here about social security, medicaid, and medicare.  These programs *are* eating up a large portion of the national budget - possibly as much as 60%- and are also sometimes called "welfare".  I think this confuses people who are discussing the issue because they hear that "welfare is taking up 60% of the budget" and think all their hard earned tax dollars are being handed out to the poor.  These programs are frequently aimed at supporting the middle and upper classes who already paid into the system, and are now cashing out.  I think it is extra important to support the new health care reform being discussed in Congress, as it will help lower the cost of insurance, medicare, and medicaid that are currently taking up so much for the budget.

Back to welfare - Anything can happen in this world, even to very good, hard working people.  You never know when you yourself might need a helping hand.  Cutting off this kindness from people who need it is not only selfish but short sighted for the good of the whole society.

Yes, we need to save money and pay off our debts here in America (we could start, for one, by not invading any more foreign countries and killing people).  I hope that people can find the compassion that they have on an individual level for their friends and family and apply it even to strangers they may never meet.  Thoughts?  Feel free to respond below.